Home, short haul or long haul? Where to make your electronics

A practical look at reshoring, nearshoring and where electronics manufacturing services fit across a product’s life.

Neil Owen, Vice President, NOTE UK

By the middle of August, most of us are either just back from somewhere or about to head off. Stand in any airport and you see the same scene: a departure board full of destinations, and a concourse full of people who have each made a different choice about where to go, and why.

I find myself thinking that decisions about where to manufacture electronics look much the same. Home in the UK, nearshore in Europe, or offshore in Asia: there is rarely one right destination. There is the right destination for this product, at this point in its life, for this reason. The skill is in reading the board.

And the answer can change. A product that flew long haul at its peak might be better brought home as volumes fall, which is really all reshoring is. The job of a good electronics manufacturing services (EMS) partner is to help you make that call at every stage, not only on day one.

Three ways to travel: home, nearshore and offshore

Broadly, every board offers three kinds of trip.

Home

Home is the staycation. Keeping production in the UK suits new product introduction, low-volume high-mix work, anything where the intellectual property is sensitive, and anything where resilience and continuity matter more than the last few pence of unit cost. It is close, it is quick to iterate, and the engineering conversation happens in the same time zone.

Short Haul

Short haul is the European city break. Nearshoring into the EU, including our own Estonia and Bulgaria operations, offers a balance: lower cost than home for the right volumes, while keeping lead times and logistics sensible and the supply chain close enough to manage comfortably.

Long Haul

Long haul is the intercontinental flight. For high-volume, mature products where unit cost at scale is the deciding factor, Asia is often the right answer, and has been for good reason for a long time.

None of this is controversial. What I think we get wrong is treating the choice as a single decision, made once, and then never revisited.

The trip that suits you changes

The kind of holiday that suits you at twenty five is not the kind that suits you at fifty five. Products are no different. Their needs change as they age, and the destination that made sense at launch may be the wrong one a few years later.

Early in life, at introduction and ramp, most products want to stay home or short haul. You need engineering support close at hand, you are still refining the design, and speed of iteration beats unit cost.

In the middle of life, at high volume and maturity, the economics can justify long haul. This is the cruising altitude phase, where scale rewards distance.

And then there is the return leg, which we talk about least and should talk about most.

The return leg: reshoring as products mature

As a product’s volumes fall away, or as it moves into end-of-life, service and spares, the case for long haul quietly weakens. Minimum order quantities that once looked efficient start to force awkward stockholding. Freight and lead times bite harder when you are shipping smaller quantities. The flexibility to build what you need, when you need it, becomes worth more than the headline cost per unit.

This is the moment to bring something back. Home or short haul, closer to the customer, with the agility to handle low volumes and protect continuity for products that still matter to the people who rely on them. Reshoring is not only a story about new products and resilience headlines. Very often it is simply the sensible final leg of a journey that began somewhere else.

Who is reading the board with you?

So the real question is not “home, short haul or long haul?” Any of the three can be right, and over a product’s life it may well be all three in turn.

The better question is who is standing at the board with you. At NOTE we deliberately run every route. Home, short haul and long haul are all ours, which means we have no reason to steer you towards one destination and every reason to help you choose the one that genuinely fits, then re-route you when the situation changes.

That, to me, is what an electronics manufacturing partner (EMS) should be. Not a single destination dressed up as the only answer, but someone who knows the whole board, flies all of it, and helps you make the right call at every stage of the trip.

Wherever you are heading this summer, I hope it is the right destination for you. And when you are back, if you are wondering whether one of your products is on the wrong route, it may be worth reading the board together.

Frequently Asked Questions